SHIELDS OF SHAME | ROSWELL POLICE DEPARTMENT | GEORGIA POST REVOCATION CASE
Matthew David Bertsch: From Roswell’s Detention Officer of the Year to Revoked Certifications
In 2013, Roswell Police recognized Matthew David Bertsch for dependability and honesty. In January 2025, Georgia POST revoked his Communications Officer and Jailer certifications following an internal investigation into his truthfulness during preparations for a GBI audit.

Agency: Roswell Police Department, Georgia
Employee: Matthew David Bertsch
Hiring date: May 25, 2004
Position: Jailer; subsequently communications officer and GCIC Terminal Agency Coordinator
Roswell investigation: Formal Investigation 2024-006
Separation: May 30, 2024, resignation in lieu of termination
POST action: January 9, 2025, revocation of Communications Officer and Jailer certifications
Nature of case: Truthfulness, prompt performance and neglect of duty findings; not an established criminal prosecution
The Recognition That Makes This Case Remarkable
Roswell Police celebrated Bertsch as its 2013 “Detention Officer of the Year,” according to the earlier Shields of Shame case reporting. The department described him as reliable and trustworthy with sensitive information. Eleven years later, the department investigated whether he had given command staff accurate information about required GCIC training compliance ahead of an anticipated state audit.

Why GCIC Compliance Matters
The Georgia Crime Information Center, operated by the GBI, supports access to criminal histories, warrants, wanted and missing persons information, stolen property, driver and vehicle information, and interconnected criminal justice records. Agencies are responsible for ensuring that personnel who access these sensitive systems meet applicable security and training requirements. The GBI describes periodic criminal justice information system audits as an important compliance control.
As the department’s Terminal Agency Coordinator, Bertsch had a central administrative responsibility for the department’s preparation and required personnel certification records. This case concerns allegedly misleading supervisors about training compliance. It is not evidence that Bertsch improperly queried individual criminal history records.
GBI official explanation of GCIC responsibilities and audits
March and April 2024: Preparing for the Audit
According to the supplied case account, Roswell Police received notice in March 2024 of an upcoming GBI audit. Communications Director John Potrzebowski began holding weekly preparation meetings. Bertsch reportedly assured supervisors that only one employee still needed to complete required GCIC certification. Subsequent review revealed that multiple employees remained noncompliant, contradicting those earlier assurances.
The investigation reportedly determined that Bertsch knew the department was significantly behind but did not promptly notify command staff. The critical issue was not merely that work remained unfinished. It was the accuracy of the information supervisors relied upon to prepare for the audit.
The Admission During the Internal Interview
“Yes, I know I led you to believe that, but I lied to you.”
The supplied case narrative attributes that admission to Bertsch during the departmental interview. It further reports that he said he feared being fired if he disclosed how far behind the department was. This is an attributed account of an internal investigation, not a criminal conviction or an independently authenticated recording.
That distinction matters because truthfulness in an administrative role directly affects an agency’s ability to demonstrate compliance with criminal justice information safeguards.
Internal Affairs Findings and Separation
Roswell Police opened Formal Investigation 2024-006. According to the supplied summary, the department sustained allegations concerning truthfulness, prompt performance of duty and neglect of duty. Bertsch resigned on May 30, 2024, in lieu of termination. A resignation in lieu of termination is not the same employment action as a completed firing, and the distinction should be retained in public reporting.
Georgia POST Revocation: January 9, 2025
Following the department’s investigation, Georgia POST reviewed Bertsch’s certification status. The supplied narrative states that the Council revoked his Communications Officer and Jailer certifications on January 9, 2025. The case describes attempted contacts and no written response from Bertsch to POST investigators. It does not establish that he was arrested, criminally prosecuted or convicted in connection with the audit incident.

Evidence Library: Original Case Documents
These documents are made available as free primary-source downloads. Readers can inspect the original wording and dates rather than relying solely on a summary. The hosted PDF contents have not been independently extracted in this editing session; the case chronology above follows the supplied narrative and previously published Shields of Shame reporting.
Case Timeline
- May 25, 2004: Bertsch joins Roswell Police as a jailer, according to the supplied case narrative.
- 2013: Department recognizes him as Detention Officer of the Year.
- 2017: Moves into communications work.
- March 2024: GBI audit notice prompts department preparation meetings.
- April 2024: Internal communications reveal substantial outstanding training compliance; interview admissions later become central to the case.
- May 30, 2024: Resigns in lieu of termination after sustained internal findings.
- June 2024: POST reportedly opens a certification investigation.
- January 9, 2025: POST revokes Communications Officer and Jailer certifications.
- November 2026: Shields of Shame organizes the case narrative and supplied evidence assets in this updated case file.
Questions Worth Pursuing
How many Roswell employees actually lacked required GCIC training? What did the weekly audit-preparation meeting notes show? When did supervisors first learn the compliance picture was inaccurate? Did the agency pass the subsequent GBI audit, and what corrective actions were implemented? What does the complete POST disciplinary order state about the legal basis and effective date of revocation? These are appropriate records-based questions, not grounds to speculate about database misuse or criminal conduct.
Where to Obtain Additional Records
Roswell Police publishes an official Georgia Open Records Act process for police and 911 records. The most useful follow-up records include Formal Investigation 2024-006, the sustained findings, relevant internal emails, audit preparation meeting notes, the GBI audit report, and POST’s final certification order. Requests should distinguish disclosable administrative records from legally restricted criminal justice information.
Roswell’s official public records request portal
Earlier Coverage and Independent Sources
- Original Shields of Shame investigation into Matthew David Bertsch
- Georgia Bureau of Investigation: GCIC responsibilities and audit oversight
- Roswell Police: Communications Division and GCIC-certified personnel
- Supplied POST case summary PDF
- Supplied Bertsch records PDF
Shields of Shame Evidence Archive
The case documents above are available to the public without a membership requirement. Additional authenticated records and contextual material may be added to the Shields of Shame investigative archive. Support independent reporting through the site’s existing membership and donations options.
Editorial and legal disclaimer: This is a public employee accountability report based on the case narrative supplied to Shields of Shame, existing Shields of Shame coverage and linked institutional background. Revocation is an administrative certification action, not a criminal conviction. No criminal charges, illegal database searches, or financial misconduct are alleged here. Quotations attributed to Bertsch come from the supplied investigation account; readers should consult the original case PDFs for complete context. Corrections supported by verifiable documentation are welcome.