Shields of Shame investigative evidence archive
This page documents the ongoing Shields of Shame investigation into the death of Jermaine Jones in Augusta, Georgia. Original records are being added individually so readers can examine the sources behind future reporting. This investigation remains in development.
GBI Investigation Documents
Evidence file 001 · PDF document
Georgia Bureau of Investigation Exhibit List
What is this document? An exhibit list is an index used to identify and organize materials associated with an investigation. The linked PDF is labeled as the GBI exhibit list for the Jermaine Jones homicide investigation. It is an inventory reference, not a substitute for the underlying exhibits.
How investigators use it: The list can help identify exhibit entries, organize evidence requests, cross-reference materials as they are obtained, and track which items have been reviewed. An entry’s presence on a list does not independently establish what an exhibit proves.
Opens the original PDF in a new tab or window, depending on browser settings.
How to Read This Investigation
Each evidence file will be labeled and explained as it is added. The archive distinguishes primary-source records from witness accounts, official findings, and Shields of Shame analysis. Records may be incomplete or redacted. Conclusions will be evaluated against the available evidence, and the page may be reorganized as the investigation develops.
Jermaine Jones Jr.: A Death, a Homicide Finding and the Records That Followed
Independent investigation by Shields of Shame. Jermaine Jones Jr., 24, died October 18, 2021, one week after a Richmond County traffic stop, TASER deployment and physical restraint. His death was classified as a homicide; the district attorney later declined criminal charges against seven officers. This investigation reconstructs the event using GBI case 07-0057-34-22, eyewitness accounts, official reporting and independently pursued public records.
EVIDENCE FILE 002 · GBI INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY · 106 PAGES
GBI Summary by ID: The Investigation Behind the Case
What it is: A compilation of Georgia Bureau of Investigation Region 7 investigative summaries, case 07-0057-34-22, documenting interviews, evidence collection, hospital inquiries, forensic work and the case disposition.
How it is used: The summary provides a dated investigative roadmap and identifies supporting evidence such as interviews, TASER logs, body-camera recordings, medical records, GPS records and forensic reports. Each summary is an investigator’s account; referenced attachments must be assessed independently.
Open GBI Investigative Summary (PDF) ↗
Opens the 106-page document in a new tab or window.
The Night a Traffic Stop Became a Death Investigation
On October 11, 2021, at approximately 7:12 p.m., a Richmond County sheriff’s investigator stopped a dark Chevrolet SUV near Highland Avenue and Clifton Street in Augusta. Willie Baker was driving; Jermaine Jones Sr. sat in the front passenger seat; and his 24-year-old son, Jermaine Jones Jr., rode in the rear. The vehicle had just left Wayne’s Towing. According to Baker’s later GBI interview, the stated reason for the stop was a license-plate cover.
Christopher Brown initiated the stop. The GBI summary identifies Richard Russell as the investigator who deployed a TASER. It also identifies Leslie Gaiter, Parker Leathers, John Tarpley, Lora Alford/Hucko and Aaron Phillips in records of the incident. The summary uses variations of some officers’ names and spellings; those will be reconciled with personnel and POST records as the archive grows.
Baker and Jones Sr. told investigators that Baker consented to a search and the three occupants were directed out of the SUV. A firearm was discovered beneath the rear passenger area. Jones Jr. moved or ran, and Russell deployed the TASER. What followed is the central disputed sequence: the fall, the physical restraint, the alleged blows and the onset of the catastrophic injuries that later killed him.
Witness Accounts: Where the Versions Diverge
In his October 12 GBI interview, Jones Sr. described officers hitting his son in the face several times while Jones Jr. was on the ground. Baker described an officer striking Jones Jr. in the back with a closed fist, but said he did not see anyone strike Jones in the head. Baker also recalled Jones saying he could not breathe. These are not identical descriptions, and they should not be merged into one supposedly established version.
Both men described Jones Jr. walking and speaking after the roadside arrest. That observation matters, but it cannot by itself establish when or how his internal injuries occurred. The timeline must be tested against the original body-camera recordings, transport video, hospital observations, autopsy findings and any available timestamps.
The GBI’s own device examination provides another precision point: Russell’s TASER X2 was recorded as having one trigger activation lasting four seconds on October 11. Investigators also determined the device clock had been 13 minutes and nine seconds slow when checked October 14. Any synchronized reconstruction must correct that offset rather than treating the raw TASER clock as exact.
The Transport and the Medical Emergency
Deputy Leslie Gaiter transported Jones following the arrest. The sheriff’s initial account to GBI said Jones developed a medical emergency while being taken toward jail and Gaiter took him to Augusta University Medical Center. Hospital nurse Ashlee Williams, recounting what she had been told, said Jones had experienced a seizure at the jail before being taken to the emergency room. These descriptions are not necessarily mutually exclusive, but they require a precise comparison with dispatch, transport GPS, hospital admission records and the camera footage.
Williams described Jones as actively seizing when he arrived and said imaging revealed severe brain trauma and bleeding. Neurosurgeon Khoi Nguyen told GBI he performed surgery and described substantial brain injury, swelling and bleeding; a subsequent scan showed additional hemorrhage and a second surgery was considered necessary. Those medical facts make the narrow public shorthand of a ‘tasing incident’ inadequate as a complete account of the death.
A Second Use-of-Force Question Inside the Hospital
The investigative record does not end at the roadside. On October 13, GBI investigators obtained nine written statements from hospital security personnel concerning interactions with Jones. A hospital security director reported an allegation that supervisor Shandrea Houser had struck Jones in the side of his body; an earlier account suggesting a strike to the head was subsequently clarified, according to the GBI summary.
That distinction is essential. The existence of a complaint is not proof of an assault, and the exact conduct, necessity and timing of any restraint must be evaluated against the original statements, medical records and any available hospital surveillance. The hospital incident warrants a separate evidence chapter rather than being buried in a story about the traffic stop.
What the GBI Collected and Examined
The GBI began work October 12. Its summary describes interviews with Jones’s father, Baker, nurses, physicians and security personnel; collection of Russell’s TASER and cartridges; roadside TASER identification markers; and SD cards containing body-worn-camera footage. The October 12 camera evidence collection lists Brown, Russell, Gaiter, Tarpley, Leathers and Phillips, while the broader evidence description also identifies Alford/Hucko.
Investigators later obtained vehicle GPS information and worked with forensic video specialists. The December 2021 summaries describe efforts to brighten, slow, crop and enlarge footage, including a file from Russell’s camera capturing the TASER deployment and fall. Those processing steps are significant: if the state needed enhancement to interpret a key moment, responsible public reporting must explain what the original image actually shows, what the enhancement clarifies, and what remains uncertain.
GBI records also document the completion of toxicology and autopsy reports in December 2021. The underlying reports, and a later third-party autopsy referenced in the closure materials, should be presented as separate source documents when added to this archive.
From Homicide Finding to No Criminal Charges
Jones died October 18, 2021, after a week in the hospital. The medical examiner’s classification of homicide is a finding about the manner of death, not automatically a determination that a particular officer committed murder or another crime. The GBI investigative file reached the Augusta Judicial Circuit District Attorney’s Office in December 2021.
On December 30, 2022, District Attorney Jared Williams informed the GBI that no criminal charges would be filed against Richard Russell, Parker Leathers, Christopher Brown, Aaron Phillips, Leslie Gaiter, John Tarpley or Lora Hucko. The GBI’s final-disposition entry records that decision and requests closure. A prosecutorial declination does not erase the medical findings, resolve every factual discrepancy or prevent scrutiny under civil-rights law, agency policy and the public’s right to inspect records.
In March 2024, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported that Jones’s family had filed a civil lawsuit against the sheriff and four deputies. Civil claims, criminal charges and a medical homicide classification apply different standards and must be described separately.
The Legal Questions the Records Raise
The stop and search. The stated plate-cover violation, the timing of consent, the scope of the vehicle search and the legal basis for any continued detention should be checked against Georgia traffic law, the Fourth Amendment and the actual camera footage. Consent from a driver can justify a vehicle search within its lawful scope, but does not answer every question about passengers’ detention.
The TASER and restraint. The constitutional analysis turns on the circumstances facing the officers at the moment force was used, including any threat, resistance or flight, and on whether later force remained reasonable once Jones was on the ground or restrained. Graham v. Connor supplies the Fourth Amendment objective-reasonableness framework. A person’s attempt to flee is relevant but does not authorize unlimited force.
Medical care. The period between the roadside restraint, transport, observed distress and hospital treatment raises separate questions about recognition of medical need, prompt response and custodial responsibility. The available evidence must establish what each participant knew and when.
The hospital. Any physical intervention by security personnel requires its own fact-specific inquiry into justification, proportionality, supervision and possible causation. The allegation of a strike must not be presented as a proven criminal offense without supporting findings.
Criminal versus civil accountability. Prosecutors’ decision not to charge officers does not necessarily foreclose civil litigation or administrative findings. Conversely, serious injuries and a homicide classification do not, standing alone, prove that a named officer violated the law.
The Records Fight: How Shields of Shame Pursued the Evidence
Shields of Shame has pursued the Jones case for years through public-records requests, research into the involved officers, body-camera review and scrutiny of agency responses. The project previously published a Georgia Open Records complaint describing efforts to obtain footage from the sheriff’s office, GBI and district attorney, and later published an audit of Richmond County’s records handling that identified a January 1, 2023 follow-up request.
According to Shields of Shame, this independent investigation has assembled and published the complete body-camera collection obtained for the incident. SOS also reports that its reporting required years of work, repeated requests, costs and contested or denied access. A fully itemized ledger of request dates, responses, fee estimates, amounts paid, denials, appeals and release dates will be added when the correspondence and receipts are placed in the evidence archive. The claim of exclusive publication is an SOS account pending a complete comparison of other outlets’ archives.
That transparency battle is part of the story, not a footnote. The public cannot meaningfully evaluate an official account if the underlying recordings, audit histories and investigative attachments remain difficult to inspect.
Timeline: Incident, Investigation and Public Reporting
Dates below distinguish the event itself from the date an outlet reported it. Each news link opens in a new tab.
- October 11, 2021, about 7:12 p.m. Traffic stop near Highland Avenue and Clifton Street; Jones is stunned, restrained and subsequently transported for medical care. GBI Exhibit 3.
- October 12, 2021, 9:45 a.m. Major Pat Young asks GBI to investigate; agents collect TASER and camera evidence and interview witnesses.
- October 12, 2021: GBI announces investigation.
- October 13, 2021: WRDW reports family’s account and severe injuries.
- October 14, 2021: Family reports devastating prognosis.
- October 14, 2021: AugustaCrime interviews Jones’s fiancée.
- October 18, 2021: Jones dies at Augusta University Medical Center.
- October 19, 2021: Mother demands access to body-camera evidence.
- November 2, 2021: News 12 examines Richard Russell’s personnel history.
- December 21, 2021: DA receives GBI investigative file.
- December 30, 2022: District attorney announces no criminal charges.
- March 28, 2024: AJC reports family’s civil lawsuit.
- December 2021: GBI documents forensic enhancement of body-camera footage and completion of autopsy and toxicology reporting.
- January 1, 2023: Shields of Shame documents a renewed records request in its Richmond County open-records audit.
Primary Sources and Related Reporting
GBI public statement · SOS open-records complaint · SOS Richmond County records audit · Associated Press reporting on Georgia TASER deaths.
Evidence Still to Be Integrated
Upcoming evidence chapters will integrate each body-camera recording and its exact timecode, officer statements and personnel records, TASER and dispatch logs, hospital-security statements, the autopsy and independent review, the civil lawsuit, and a dated open-records correspondence and fee ledger. Each document will receive its own downloadable evidence card.
Editorial and legal notice: This page distinguishes allegations, witness recollections, official findings and independent analysis. No named person is deemed guilty of a crime solely because they appear in an investigative record. Medical classification of homicide does not itself determine criminal liability. The article will be updated as source material is verified and added.